Farida borrowed 25,000 afghani to have her teeth treated. She had several teeth extracted during two visits to the clinic. When she arrived for the third time to continue the dental work, she was sent home. Only later did she learn why. In a phone call, the clinic told her that an order had come from vice and virtue officials that male doctors must not treat women. 

Farida was left with both pain and debt. The money she could have used to see another doctor had already been spent. Her story appeared in a joint Zan Times and Guardian report on November 12, 2026, which changed her real name to a pseudonym for her safety.

Farida’s treatment required several visits. After the first two visits, she expected that her doctor would be at work and ready to continue the treatment. The intervention of Taliban officials took away this simple assurance. 

For a woman who cannot afford to pay again for the same procedure, losing one appointment can mean losing the whole course of treatment. Now, if that woman needs surgery or ongoing care, she must hope at each and every stage that the orders won’t change, that staff will be allowed to work, and that the clinic that accepted her yesterday will accept her tomorrow. In today’s Afghanistan, the Taliban make women’s access to treatment dependent on the presence of female health workers, while they themselves have closed or restricted the paths to education and work for those very women.

Zan Times’s report on the widespread trouble women have obtaining necessary dentistry rests on conversations with women and clinic staff in 14 provinces. Staff in all of those provinces reported being visited by vice and virtue officials, who threatened to jail male doctors or close clinics. 

To discover what was happening in other fields of medicine, Zan Times spoke with doctors in six provinces. Their accounts indicate that in some facilities, examination and even emergency care for a woman were made conditional on the presence of a mahram or the involvement of a female health worker. The reporting of such experiences indicates the breadth of the problem.  More data is needed to discover what is happening in each district in all 34 provinces of Afghanistan, or how many women have gone without treatment across the country.  Some information is coming to light, including UNAMA’s report on human rights, which recorded Taliban orders to male dentists in Kandahar city in September 2025. That appears to be the beginning of the nationwide de facto restriction on women obtaining help from male dentists.

To understand how this restriction is enforced, one must distinguish between an announced order and what a doctor experiences at the clinic door. According to the joint Zan Times-Guardian report, the ban on male dentists treating women had not been publicly announced. The same report cites how, in February, Hamdullah Nomani, the Taliban’s minister of communications, stated that a male doctor can examine a female patient. Under the current system, a minister’s word carries practical weight for a doctor only if the local vice and virtue officials also abide by it and the doctor can invoke it during an inspection. 

When a clinic’s survival depends on the local official’s interpretation, its manager may preemptively turn away women who, in other circumstances, would have found a way to be examined. For the restriction to spread across a community and a province, a vice and virtual official need not visit every clinic every day. The memory of one inspection and the threat of closure can change staff’s daily decisions.

As well, the mahram requirement shifts part of the work of securing treatment onto the household. A woman must first find someone who can go with her. If that man is a daily-wage laborer, accompanying her may cost the family a day’s pay. If travel to another city is needed, the family must pay fares and expenses for two people and account for the time it takes both of them to return. 

For a woman who has no close relative available, or whose pain is not taken seriously by others in her home, the difficulty begins with the very first decision. In such circumstances, distance from a hospital must be measured against the time and money a woman has to reach it. The nearest clinic on the map may be harder for her to reach than a clinic in another province. As a result, women who have money and the means to travel appear in city hospital statistics, while women who stay at home are left out of the patient count. Thus, a drop in visits may signal that the path to the front door has grown harder, not that the need for treatment has fallen.

When accompaniment becomes a condition of examination, a woman also loses part of her control over her conversation with the doctor. A woman who wants to talk about violence at home or pain in an intimate part of her body may not say everything in front of her relative. The doctor, in turn, decides on treatment based on what he hears. In this way, a woman can reach the hospital and have her name entered in the patient register, yet still not receive the examination or treatment she truly needs. Richard Bennett’s report to the Human Rights Council examines the connection between women’s and girls’ access to health services and those restrictions on movement and access.

Doctors and nurses also face the consequences of these de facto orders issued by the Taliban. The Zan Times-Guardian report includes cases where part of an examination was handed to a female nurse because the male doctor was not allowed direct contact with the patient. Medicine has always been teamwork, and dividing tasks according to training and skill can benefit the patient. Problems arise when fear of inspection sets the limits of each person’s duties. A nurse may be pressured into work she has not been trained for, and a doctor may be held responsible for a decision whose basis he could not directly examine. If something goes wrong, a woman should know who was responsible for her treatment and where she can complain. Changing how examinations are done in order to satisfy Taliban rules blurs that responsibility as well.

In Faryab, a doctor told Zan Times that their hospital needs a female anesthesia specialist. If a hospital has a female surgeon and nurse, it still needs someone who can anesthetize the patient and monitor her during the operation in order to carry out surgery. The absence of a single specialist can hold up the work of an entire team. Seen this way, counting the women employed at a hospital does not give a full picture of the services that women can receive. One must look at which specialty is available, in which department, and at what hour of what day.

A March 2026 World Health Organization assessment, citing 2023 data, reported a combined total of about 10.3 doctors, nurses and midwives per 10,000 people in Afghanistan. The same assessment cites an estimate that women made up 27 percent of general practitioners, 18 percent of specialists and 29 percent of nurses. Those low shares help explain why female patients cannot always find female doctors in a needed specialty in their region of the country. 

This same difficulty also changes preventive care. Hospitals expect patients to come before an illness becomes severe. A woman who must persuade several people, raise money, and make sure she will be seen each time she goes to a health facility may put off a visit until the pain becomes unbearable. In its report on maternal and child health services, WHO put Afghanistan’s maternal mortality ratio at 521 deaths per 100,000 live births. This figure shows the underlying vulnerability; estimating deaths caused by the new restrictions would require separate data. In a country where maternal deaths are this high, timely access to antenatal care, help during childbirth, and emergency referrals to hospital can each affect a patient’s fate.

In coming years, a shortage at examination appointments will become entangled with another ominous trend. The Taliban closed universities to women in December 2022. UNAMA’s report on the last quarter of 2024 recorded that, on December w 2024, the Taliban’s deputy minister of public health verbally told representatives of medical institutes that girls and women would no longer be allowed to attend class as of the next day. The institutes offered fields such as midwifery, nursing, dental care, anesthesia, and laboratory sciences. Closing the universities cut off the training of female doctors, and closing the institutes shut the other routes by which women entered different parts of the health services across the country. A student whose studies were left half-finished and a girl not yet old enough to enroll have been stopped at two different points on the same road. Reopening classrooms would mean something different for each, and it would take years for both to reach the workforce.

UNICEF estimated in April 2026 that if restrictions on girls’ education and women’s work continue, Afghanistan could lose up to 5,400 female health workers by 2030. This figure is a conditional projection. When a health worker retires or leaves for any reason, a newly trained person is usually expected to take their place. Now, even one person’s long leave, transfer, or retirement can mean a break in service for a small facility with no one available to act as a capable replacement. Moreover, many clinical skills are learned while training alongside someone who has seen patients for years and can guide a trainee’s hand at a difficult moment. If a gap opens between generations, rebuilding teams will take a long time even after the ban is lifted.

UNAMA recorded that, in September 2025, Kandahar virtue and vice officials required health facilities to ensure that women have a mahram while at work and that the mahram stayed on site for the entire shift. If the worker has a night shift, this requirement effectively makes an entire family’s life subordinate to the hospital’s schedule. Someone who can take his sister or wife to work may not be able to stay there for hours. Each time a hospital needs such an arrangement to fill a shift, keeping the service running depends on the time and income of people not employed by the hospital. Making work harder for trained women, just when the country needs them most, reduces facilities’ capacity in tangible ways.

Some women prefer to talk to a female doctor and to see her for private examinations. Offering that choice respects the patient and can make it easier for women to seek care. When a Taliban official dictates the doctor’s gender and closes off other options, the patient loses the choice she once had, even in an emergency. 

In an illness that needs ongoing examination, trust in a doctor builds over several visits. A woman should be able to decide with whom to continue treatment and under what conditions to consent to an examination. If this decision is taken from her, her control over her own body is limited both at home and in the clinic. 

Farida, who borrowed money hoping to be freed from the torment of her aching teeth, lost her money before obtaining relief. Instead, her right to treatment was taken from her, and the power to free herself from her pain no longer rests with her. What women experience in healthcare involves – in multiple layers – discrimination, loss of agency, denial of the right to decide, and no guarantee of the right to receive medical care. In Afghanistan, a sick woman has to worry about getting all these obstacles, while also having to deal with the illness that started her down this tortuous path. 

Tamana Aref is a freelance writer and a political science student at Sapienza University of Rome.

Leave a comment